8 Nostalgic Y2K Accessories That Will Be Everywhere This Fall
:upscale()/2025/08/22/726/n/49352476/76aae9a968a89a18df6b52.84562433_.png)
While summer still has several weeks left on the calendar, the anticipation for fall is stronger than ever — and for good reason. From morning runs in that crisp, autumn air to engaging in wholesome holidays like Thanksgiving, the September 22 solstice couldn't come fast enough. Among the many pleasures the seasonal transition brings, we're most excited for the style. While TikTok is bound to usher in a new wave of fashion fads to inform our fall shopping, we're also gravitating to a few picks that aren't exactly new, but just as referential as any "it" trend — from butterfly stud earrings to charmcore.
One may think: when did nostalgic accessories come back? But the reality is, the allure of nostalgic accessories never actually left the sartorial trend cycle. They may have traveled down the ladder, but have always been around. Since Y2K's resurgence in 2020, we've seen the obsession with all things early aughts endure in recent years, from Taylor Swift's cosign of friendship bracelets during her "Eras" tour takeover to Hailey Bieber's recent dominance in the polka dot renaissance. And we predict the nostalgic madness is going to continue through this fall. Of course, we've done all the legwork for you and curated a simple guide to the chicest accessories to nail the timeless trend, from the best destination: Claire's. We scoured the all-American retailer's site for everything you need to live out your best throwback fantasy this season. Another plus? All picks are under $20.
:upscale()/2025/08/20/926/n/49352476/a3136bb2ca30f19c_Screenshot_2025-08-20_at_5.13.28_PM.png)
Lip Gloss
Claire's Light Pink Glaze Lip Oil ($8)
Anyone else having a nostalgic rush looking at this Claire's lip oil? Us too. Lip oils have been all the rage in recent years, and this pink glaze is a great way to get in on the action.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/20/927/n/44344577/shoppqKP6J.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/20/927/n/49352476/4bbbbfb768a63b0424b077.98660526_Screenshot_2.png)
A Scrunchie
Claire's Giant Hot Pink Satin Hair Scrunchie ($10)
From Fashion Week street style to TikTok, you can't go wrong with a scrunchie. They're an easy, tension-free way to style your hair and come in countless iterations, like this chic pink one.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/20/911/n/44344577/shop7WB2MM.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/20/930/n/49352476/9cd80e2668a63bda31c963.81065784_Screenshot_2.png)
Friendship Bracelets
Claire's Best Friends Gold-Tone Chain Bracelets ($10)
Whether you're a die-hard Swiftie or are just obsessed with your best friend, you'll want to snag these gold bracelets. Made with a sleek, gold-tone "BFF" design, you can wear them with any look — from a LBD with boots for a girls' night out to day errands with a classic denim-on-denim outfit.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/20/908/n/44344577/shopIkwWDa.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/25/716/n/49352476/b805ec17bd851fe5_Screenshot_2025-08-25_at_12.11.39_PM.png)
A Scrunchie Scarf
Claire's Lilac Satin Small Hair Scrunchie Scarf ($10)
For those days when you can't decide if you want to wear a scrunchie or a scarf, enter the perfect hybrid accessory from Claire's. Ideal for any hairstyle from ponytails and buns to braids, you can get the look of a long scarf without compromising security, thanks to its scrunchie detailing. Not to mention, it's super chic.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/25/718/n/44344577/shopNgop2U.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/20/937/n/49352476/580cdcc1f1de680c_Screenshot_2025-08-20_at_5.28.48_PM.png)
A Lip Gloss Keychain
Claire's Yellow Daisy Lip Gloss Keychain ($10)
Calling all lip gloss fanatics, we found the perfect product for you. This keychain is a two-in-one find you'll never want to lose. It comes with a keyring to attach all of your daily must-haves on and a guava-flavored lip gloss to keep your lips moisturized all day long.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/20/946/n/44344577/shophSdWpf.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/20/931/n/49352476/ef9b1ccca6d5880d_Screenshot_2025-08-20_at_5.16.44_PM.jpg)
A Claw Clip
Claire's Blue Tortoiseshell Rectangular Hair Claw ($10)
Whether you're embracing luscious curls this fall or sporting a '90s blowout, you can never go wrong with a claw clip. This blue tortoiseshell style brings personality and elegance to any hairstyle, from a messy bun to the Y2K spillover updo.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/20/932/n/44344577/shopGXZME6.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/20/959/n/49352476/9863dec88f06f1ce_Screenshot_2025-08-20_at_6.00.46_PM.png)
Butterfly Earrings
Claire's Bright Butterfly Stud Earrings ($15)
Butterflies for fall? Groundbreaking. Whether you're headed to the Backstreet Boys residency or a Y2K-themed party, these studs are a no-brainer purchase.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/20/960/n/44344577/shopsgSfNN.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/25/712/n/49352476/1bb108729e0de0a7_Screenshot_2025-08-25_at_12.05.04_PM.png)
A Water Bottle
Claire's Blue Chrome Stainless Steel Handled Tumbler ($30)
While tumblers seem like a recent trend, they were just as popular in the early aughts. We love this vibrant blue style from Claire's that features a futuristic chrome design, functional handle, and tapered bottom for convenience. Whether you're a gym fanatic or like to stay hydrated, you'll never want to put this stylish tumbler down.
:extract_cover():upscale():fill(ffffff)/2025/08/25/714/n/44344577/shopTPyiXm.jpg)
:upscale()/2025/08/05/234/n/49352476/b04e03cbb8ff8373_Commerce_Mini_Bio_Slides.png)
Naomi Parris is an assistant shopping editor at Popsugar, based in New York. With over eight years of experience and previous roles held on the brand's Beauty and Operations teams, she enjoys telling stories that merge fashion, beauty, and Black culture. Naomi has also lent her skillful pen to Essence Girls United, Elle, Bustle, and Elite Daily. When she's not crafting shopping roundups, high-profile features, beauty op-eds, or trend guides, you can find Naomi behind her blog "Eli-Nay," where she inspires readers through style guides, cultural pieces, and innovative content on her Instagram.
